Columbus Day to Thanksgiving Reading

One of the B-list holidays in America is Columbus Day, which falls next week – celebrating (or not) the “discovery” of the New World by the intrepid Italian-sailing-for-Spain navigator a mere 517 years ago.  Every American school child knows that “in 1492, Columbus sailed the ocean blue…” and in a few weeks we’ll celebrate Thanksgiving with turkey and corn and decorations with funny hats with buckles on them – commemorating the “First Thanksgiving” celebrated by the Pilgrims, Squanto and his pals the year after their founding of Plymouth in 1620 – something else that every American school child knows.

But there’s a problem here.  There are 128 years between Columbus and the Pilgrims – and most Americans probably can’t tell you anything about the intervening years.  Kids in Virginia will tell you about Jamestown being founded in 1607 – though you can guarantee they don’t know that Santa Fe, New Mexico was founded in 1608 — or that St. Augustine Florida beat them both by 40+ years.

And such is the thesis for a great book I finished reading last month “A Voyage Long and Strange” by Tony Horwitz.  In this book, the author tracks down the “missing” history between Columbus and the Pilgrims.  He interweaves the history with a sort of odd travelogue where he visits the colonial sites of yore in the present day.  In fact, he begins with a trip to Newfoundland and an investigation of the Norse colonies there about 500 years BEFORE Columbus.

The book is witty and also sad.  Horwitz’ writing captures well that “stranger in a strange land” feeling as he goes across North America in search of the historical truth of this often-neglected era.  Along the way, the saddest parts are those in which historical evidence is ignored so that certain myths can be fostered – usually for civic and personal gain.

Almost as remarkable are the forgotten histories of many of the Spanish explorers in the New World — the most remarkable is probably that of Alvar de Vaca, who’s journey in the New World made the Lewis and Clark Expedition of the 19th century look like a Cub Scout camping trip.

But of course, since Anglophiles were writing American history books, all this is often ignored to pump up the image of the fearless Captain Smith and Pocahontas of Jamestown (though they probably leave out the cannibalism there in the second harsh winter), and extol the determined, Puritan work-ethic of the Pilgrims also leaving out their own religious persecution of those that disagreed with them.

I encourage everyone that wants a good yarn and to learn a little more about our own history of which we are too willfully ignorant.

Oh – and the first Thanksgiving between Europeans and Native Americans in what is now the US was in Florida and probably consisted of a pesole-like pork stew and corn.   Remember that next month!

Read and post comments |
Send to a friend


15 thoughts on “Columbus Day to Thanksgiving Reading

  1. I read that book and really enjoyed it. So much of the history we are taught is inaccurate. It's amazing and sad. Have you read Lies My Teacher Told Me: Everything Your American History Textbook Got Wrong by James W. Loewen?

  2. RP — I haven't read that book, but I'll have to look for it — next time that I want to simultaneously be informed and annoyed at what mistakenly is perceived as "history". I really enjoyed this book.

  3. I've just finished reading: "Crazy for the Storm" by Norman Ollstad. He was a competative skier at age 11 and survived a plane crash. Well written and inspirational for me.

  4. Are you really that clueless, ken? By putting the word discovery in quotation marks he was pointing out that Columbus did not really discover the New World. He did, however, point out its existence to the Europeans. I guess he deserves some recognition for that.

  5. ok i will humbly say i'm sorry,so by doing the same thing to thanksgiving day he was making the same point??? and the northern indians that talk about those tall blond people from the sea meant what????
    and hows your court case going over there,did they really stick it to that drug store owner..

  6. As for Thanksgiving, there's no record that the Norse did anything but attack and try to kill the local natives in Newfoundland — so, unlikely that they hung out to enjoy the harvest.

  7. I'm catching up on the Vox hood so just saw this post. I have this book at home on my shelf. I'll definitely have to pick it up soon! I second Red Pen's suggestion of Lies My Teacher Told Me. I loved that book.

  8. first of all look to newfoundland and nova scotia,they have both found long houses that were built with norse tools,that they spent two and three years at some places if not longer,is a fact.
    as far as thanksgiving,its where history and tradition say it happened,there will always someone who can point to some abscure fact and say it happened here or's like people claiming that washington wasn't the first president.there was a time you could get smacked in the back of the head for such ''facts''

  9. Ken — if you'd read the post, you'd see that I mentioned that —-In fact, he begins with a trip to Newfoundland and an investigation of the Norse colonies there about 500 years BEFORE Columbus.They were there for at least a decade, though eventually abandoned the colony. If you take "Thanksgiving" as a harvest festival between European colonists and Native Americans, there are several first hand accounts from Spanish explorers describing such an occurrence, well before the Pilgrims.Of course, the Norse probably DID have their own "Thanksgivings" — for harvests, or hunts, or just making the voyage across the North Atlantic. There's no historical evidence, "abscure" or otherwise, to suggest they had anything but confrontations with the locals.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s