Book Review: The City and The City, by China Mieville

One of my favorite books from a couple of years ago was Kraken by China Mieville. I enjoyed that audiobook so much that there was a part of me that had some trepidation about reading more of Mieville’s books because I worried that maybe they wouldn’t be as good as that first one, right? Please tell me that I’m not the only person that feels this way when they first discover a new writer or band.

Anyway, I overcame my perhaps unwarranted hesitancy and read Mieville’s novel previous to Kraken: The City and The City. At its core, it’s a detective novel. The setting is the rival Eastern European-ish cities of Beszel and Ul Qoma. A woman from one city is found dead in the other and haggard Beszel detective Tyador Borlu must work through the barriers in his own corrupt department as well as navigate the other city-state’s unfamiliar customs and inherent distrust to solve the crime.

Now, this might sound all pretty straightforward, but Mieville’s innovation is the locale. Beszel and Ul Qoma aren’t neighboring cities like East and West Berlin, or Buda and Pest. Their streets and buildings literally co-occupy the same space. This creates an environment in which citizens of one city are required to “unsee” and “unhear” the citizens of the other, even though they might be walking down the same street or sitting on the same park bench. Monitoring everyone from both cities is the (almost) all-seeing secret police, Breach, which ruthlessly “disappears” offenders that break the rules of separation.

The City & The City

Of course, Mieville is too subtle a writer to spell things out with exposition. He just dunks you right in and makes you figure the nuances of this world out for yourself. For me, this caused the first several chapters to be downright disorienting. And I found that slightly off-balance feeling staying with me during the entire book – which I’m pretty sure was the intention all along.

The overlapping cities and the beaten down, paranoid police-state culture that comes with it are the real stars of the book and create a palpable noir feel. Of course, the construct invites clear parallels to our own society, whether it’s “unseeing” the homeless person you walk past everyday, or “unhearing” facts that disagree with your own political worldview, or having a population that’s willfully ignorant. These contemplations lingered with me long after I put the book down.

The City and The City is solid detective mystery set in one of the most original backgrounds I’ve come across in a long time that can even induce a little self-reflection. See? Nothing to worry about.

Four solid stars.


13 thoughts on “Book Review: The City and The City, by China Mieville

    • Cloud — give him a shot. I’ve read 3 so far (including the one after Kraken, which was Embassytown) — all of them were very different but good.

    • Lauri — I think he’s an author you’ll know pretty early whether you like him or not. I’m not sure which book to suggest for going first, because every one I’ve read has been very different.

  1. Added to my Goodreads “to read” shelf, which, alas, is becoming very long. I haven’t read any Mieville yet, but I felt that way when I discovered Jo Nesbo’s Redbreast. I noticed he’d written other books recently translated into English, but I worried that they wouldn’t be up to the expectations set by Redbreast. I finally decided it was unfair to the author not to read his other works because of an irrational concern, and picked up The Devil’s Star and The Reckoning. I liked the latter more than the former, but the quality of writing was still there, as was his ability to create interesting characters. I wish I could say the same of Tolkien or Christie or a few other classic writers whom I’ve loved over the years. It must be hard to write consistently well over a long career of many bestsellers, I’d guess.

    • HG –I have Nesbo (I can’t type that O-slash thing) and Redbreast on my to-read list! So there you go.

      I think it has to be hard for an author not to get drawn into the traps of writing a series because after a while, I think they end up being TOO similar. I’m not sure how you can go to the same well again and again without it seeming formulaic. Fortunately, I’ve read 3 Mieville books so far and they’re all quite different.

  2. Pingback: Cultural Considerations « The World Writ Small

  3. Pingback: Cultural Considerations

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s